About Us

The Nightmare Shop launched in 2016 in St. Louis, Missouri. But if you're reading this and are a horror enthusiast like we are, then you know as well as we do that it all began on the streets of Haddonfield, the foggy banks of the Black Lagoon, or in the boiler room where our nightmares came to life. Our mission is to make your darkest nightmares come true and make all things from masks, records, movies, pop culture collections, and anything the horror genre offers to be accessible for all of you die hard horror fans.  To get a little more into it, we're two guys (Greg- left, John- right) from St. Louis who grew up together eating, sleeping, and breathing horror films. Our love for the genre as a whole started off strong by watching cult classics such as The Texas Chainsaw Massacre and Alien on our living room floors as young children. Then, it grew into an even stronger Dr. Frankenstein type madness that needed to be brought to life for all of us horror hounds who have been howling to the full moon for more horror accessibility. That's why we're here. To be your gateway to horror. To bring you the most satisfying experience buying the horror memorabilia you need for your own ultimate collection! Scare on and unleash your deepest and darkest Nightmares at The Nightmare Shop, where all your Nightmares come true. . . Thanks for visiting! 

Can't find what you're looking for? Drop us a line and we will do our best to find it for you!


John Ehrhard & Greg Stelzer

(Co-founders, Owners and Operators)